Good without feedback
I recently got some practice in prose, working on a new article (in Russian) for the media channels of the Clubs. And to be honest, working on the article was very hard morally. And no, not because I’m no specialist in verbiage, I have generally always been fine with that, but because once again I was doing something whose negative effect is obvious, namely lost time, while the positive one is hard to measure at the very least, if not illusory altogether. “Maybe they really do watch only TikToks?”, “Who will even get through this long read?”, “Will they reach these priceless quotes, or will they close it because they see some face they dislike?”
In non-profit and near-altruistic work this effect haunts you constantly, and over the years it only demotivates more. When you are a young, energetic idealist with no strict obligations to an employer, a family and other people who share the same “boat” with you, all this comes relatively easily, because the “fine” for being a “good guy” is low and it is easier to accept a low return. Although even in those years, as I recall, I tried, following a certain intuition, to get good deeds (not only my own, naturally) recognised among the people around me. As an adult you feel these sacrifices many times more sharply.
And here you are once again, holding a handful of hours of your life, standing somewhere on a mountain and performing the already familiar mental ritual: you imagine that something more worthwhile will surely grow out of this, something that will cover what it cost you, and then you throw it down. And again the world answers with silence at best, and at worst with some spit typical of the situation. This, apparently, is how people burn out, people who are ready to change something, as they lose touch with the “ground”, with those they are doing things for.
We could do so much if we found the strength and time to notice the good around us and to support those who have made our lives better. It’s a pity this rarely happens.
More about actions and their long-term consequences. In teaching there are always moments when you think “god, why on earth am I even doing this” (though the same question can catch up with you in any line of work when you are extremely tired).
It is, actually, a very useful question. Once I was thinking about it and found a lens that was very interesting to me, which I once shared with some of the Clubs members.
Imagine that you have some authority. You didn’t particularly strive for it (at least not consciously), but life naturally created a situation in which you have it; for example, you are somewhat older than the person you are talking to and at least look like someone who has “figured something out about life”.
For me, over my years of study, many lecturers of the computer science faculty turned out to be such people, including those whose personality sometimes went against my grain. It is, in general, an effect that is easy to observe but hard to prove: older people can always teach you something you don’t understand, even if their character on the whole doesn’t appeal to you.
And now imagine that you are in the place of the people you once fed on. The responsibility is, actually, big: you have to try to be at least no worse. But here is what is more interesting: it is a big opportunity. In a single year some 40–50 people can pass by a lecturer. Decades of work mean thousands of people who have passed by you. The imagination immediately draws a picture of a chain reaction which, given enough “inertia” in the links, spreads across the whole country and the whole world.
And here is the trouble: just as with writing an article, there is practically no feedback in this work. Neither about the benefit of the lectures and practical classes, nor about the “conversations between the lines”. And worse still, a person may not even realise how exactly some word dropped in passing affected them. So it turns out that, unlike many crafts where the worker gets feedback simply because a system of product reviews fits perfectly into a market economy, “mentoring” as an occupation leaves a person at least partly uncertain about the results of their work.