RUEN

← home

Live recordings instead of studio ones

Arttelegram

Recently Artyom Kudyakov and I were privately discussing our views on music. In that conversation I touched on one interesting thing.

I used to be a big fan of studio music. Listening to live recordings seemed strange and incomprehensible to me: why would I want a version with an out-of-breath artist and the crowd shouting from the hall when there is the pure concentrate of the work.

Today, on the contrary, I have become very positive about videos with the words live, drum cam, piano cover. And here is why.

First, for me music is above all about a person. About their emotions and feelings. Somewhere between the music and the lyrics there is a third dimension, which is much less noticeable but more interesting.

Second, it is a chance to bring your eyes into the perception of music. Many people think we hear with our ears, but visual experience plays a huge role in how we perceive sound. It is much easier to break a drum part into pieces once you have had that “whoa, what a low drum, that’s a tom, right? cool!” moment. This way of perceiving not only lets you take music apart into atoms better, but also lets you truly appreciate the artist’s skill.

Third, it is a good chance to hear favourite songs in an unfamiliar arrangement. Studio versions really do get stale, especially when you have been a listener for ten years. But every live performance is special. It has the artist’s mood of the moment, the unrepeatable energy of the hall and an element of chance.

Here are a few live videos, very different in format, that really do give a unique listening experience.

  1. Twenty One Pilots — Storyteller Performance: a unique reworking of hits you have already grown tired of
  2. Noize MC — Yes Future (Drum Cam): personally, I badly underestimated how hard the part is until I saw it played live
  3. The bassist took over Zilkov’s band (in Russian): just realise that nobody there is playing their own role (absolutely everyone swapped instruments)
  4. Muse — Madness: it so happens that I’m not that big a fan of this band, but Bogdan Ustyushin shared this live with me, and I was struck by how much more alive than the original it turned out
  5. Jacob Collier — Sleeping On My Dreams (Live in Lisbon): he is simply a genius of our time, but it is extremely hard to understand that without seeing what he does live.