Skin in the game
Completely by accident I remembered that on my shelf there is a book by Nassim Taleb, “Skin in the Game”. I had read a comparatively small part of it (as, in general, I often do with other books), but today I reread it and thought it would be a good idea to continue the tradition of sharing interesting things.
So. In my student years it was vitally necessary for me to discuss things concerning society. Like what the anarcho-capitalists actually meant, what role the “traitors” played in the collapse of the USSR, where it’s actually a blast and you probably don’t even have to die.
About a year ago, whenever such questions came up again, either «Слова-паразиты» (“Filler Words”) or «Метафизика» (“Metaphysics”) would start surfacing in my head. In other words, I simply got dead tired of endlessly discussing things, unless my goal is to “test” a new acquaintance’s views.
Coming back to the book, Taleb seems to have a very precise formulation of my views on such philosophical conversations (the quote is translated back from the Russian edition):
“Putting your skin in the game is necessary not only to be fair, financially successful and to manage risk; it is necessary to understand the world. It is <…> about identifying and filtering nonsense, <…>, telling academia (in the bad sense of the word) from the real world. <…>. If you have voiced an opinion and someone has taken it into account, you have a moral obligation to face the consequences.”
These three sentences contain several important theses at once:
- “Skin in the game” is a good source of knowledge and a good strength test for the knowledge you already have.
- The absence of responsibility for your words (in the broad sense) invites misleading both yourself and the people around you.
- Excessive faith in science, unconditional recognition of the authority of “scientists” who may have read a lot of letters, though not necessarily good ones, tears you off the “ground”: “thou shalt not make unto thee an idol”.
The last point is especially difficult, because denying all authority is no less dangerous.
In short, chatting without “raising the stakes” has simply become boring.
Constantly avoiding responsibility inevitably leads to regress, of an individual person and of the society they are part of. And it seems that today this is a fairly widespread “disease”.
TLDR.
Talk is cheap. Show me the code.